Washington State Patrol, Decision 8436 (PSRA, 2004)

Lyle Loncosty, Employee Relations Specialist, for the union.

Juliet Wehr Jones, Labor & Risk Manager, for the em­ployer.

On January 28, 2004, the Washington State Patrol (employer) filed a petition for clarification of a bargaining unit with the Public Employment Relations Commission under WAC 391-35-026, seeking division of an existing bargaining unit at the State Fire Mar­shall’s Office represented by Washington Public Employees Associa­tion, United Food and Commercial Workers Union (UFCW), Local 365, (union). An investigation conference was conducted on February 19, 2004, by Hearing Officer Starr H. Knutson.

The Executive Director accepts the stipulations and information presented by the parties during the investigation conference and, acting under WAC 391-35-026(1), divides the historical bargaining unit into two separate bargaining units of state civil service employees conforming to RCW 41.80.070(1) (a), as follows: (1) a bargaining unit of non-supervisory employees; and (2) a bargaining unit of supervisors.

BACKGROUND

The employer is a state agency which provides public safety services to the residents of Washington State. The union has historically represented several bargaining units of this employer.

The bargaining unit was created in 1987,[1] at the Washington State Department of Community Development. Subsequently, the Legislature moved the Office of Fire Protection Services, which included the State Fire Marshall’s Office, to the Washington State Patrol. The bargaining unit has been in its present form since 2000.[2] That unit has historically included both supervisors and non-supervisory employees.

The Personnel System Reform Act of 2002 (PSRA) was passed by the Legislature and signed into law in 2002, with various effective dates. A new collective bargaining system for state civil service employees is codified in Chapter 41.80 RCW, of which one section that took effect on June 13, 2002, is pertinent here:

RCW 41.80.070 BARGAINING UNITS -- CERTIFICATION. (1) A bargaining unit of employees covered by this chapter existing on June 13, 2002, shall be considered an appropriate unit, unless the unit does not meet all the requirements of (a) . . . of this subsection. The commission, after hearing upon reasonable notice to all interested parties, shall decide, in each application for certification as an exclusive bargaining representative, the unit appropriate for certification. In determining the new units or modification of existing units, the commission shall consider: the duties, skills and working conditions of the employees; the history of collective bargaining; the extent of organization among the employ­ees; the desires of the employees; and the avoidance of excessive fragmentation. However, a unit is not appro­priate if it includes:

(a)                Both supervisors and non-supervisory employees.

 . . .

(emphasis added). The Commission thus adopted a rule to implement that statute during the transition period which will exist until the duty to bargain under the new system goes into effect on July 1, 2004, as follows:

WAC 391-35-026 SPECIAL PROVISION -- STATE CIVIL SERVICE EMPLOYEES. In addition to the circumstances described in WAC 391-35-020, bargaining units of state civil service employees may be modified under this section until RCW 41.80.050 and 41.80.080 take effect on July 1, 2004.

(1) Bargaining units of state civil service employ­ees in existence on June 13, 2002, shall be subject to being “divided” into separate units of supervisors and nonsupervisory employees under this section.

(a) A petition to have an existing unit divided may be filed by the exclusive bargaining representative, by the employer, or by those parties jointly.

(b) The separation of bargaining units shall be implemented on or before July 1, 2004.

. . . .

(emphasis added). By the stipulation now before the Executive Director, the parties seek to have the historical unit “divided” under WAC 391-35-026(1).

ANALYSIS

Applicable Legal Standards

The determination and modification of appropriate bargaining units of state civil service employees is now a function delegated by the Legislature to the Public Employment Relations Commission. RCW 41.06.340; 41.80.070. In past cases where parties have stipulated to divide bargaining units to conform with statutory changes, the Commission has accepted such stipulations and dispensed with a full hearing process. Benton County, Decision 2221 (PECB, 1985) and Cowlitz County, Decision 5008 (PECB, 1995) (dividing historical department-wide units in sheriff’s departments after the law enforcement officers became eligible for interest arbitration); King County, Decision 6668 (PECB, 1999) (dividing historical units to reflect the eligibility of some of the employees (those working in public transit operations) for interest arbitration).

The processing of this case is greatly simplified by the parties’ agreement that the historical bargaining unit configuration created under different statutory provisions than now exist must be divided to conform to the current statute.

FINDINGS OF FACT

1.                  The Washington State Patrol is a general government agency of the state of Washington within the meaning of RCW 41.80.005(1).

2.                  The Washington Public Employees Association, UFCW Local 365, is an employee organization within the meaning of RCW 41.80.005(7).

3.                  The Washington Federation of State Employees represents the historical bargaining unit described by the Washington Personnel Resources Board on April 26, 2000, in RU-544. That unit historically included all employees in the State Fire Marshall’s Office, except the administrative assistant.

4.                  The employer and the union have stipulated that the historical bargaining unit configuration is not appropriate under RCW 41.80.070, and that the historical bargaining unit should be divided into separate units of supervisors and non-supervisory employees.

5.                  The employer and the union have stipulated to the respective eligibility lists for the separate units of supervisors and non-supervisory employees.

6.                  No other facts have been discovered or brought to the atten­tion of the Executive Director which call into question the propriety of the stipulations described in paragraphs 3 and 4 of these findings of fact.

CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

1.                  The Public Employment Relations Commission has jurisdiction in this matter under Chapter 41.80 RCW and WAC 391-35-026.

2.                  The bargaining unit historically known as the “State Fire Marshall’s Office Bargaining Unit” is inappropriate under RCW 41.80.070, by reason of its inclusion of a mix of supervisors and non-supervisory employees.

3.                  The stipulations of the parties to divide the historical bargaining unit will implement the requirements of RCW 41.80.070(1) (a).

ORDER

The bargaining unit shall be divided into two bargaining units described as follows:

1.                  All non-supervisory civil service employees of the Washington State Patrol State Fire Marshall’s Office excluding confiden­tial employees, internal auditors, supervisors, Washington Management Service employees (on and after July 1, 2004), employees in other bargaining units and employees historically excluded from the unit by orders of the Washington Personnel Resources Board or its predecessors.

2.                  All supervisory civil service employees of the Washington State Patrol State Fire Marshall’s Office excluding confiden­tial employees, internal auditors, non-supervisors, Washington Management Service employees (on and after July 1, 2004), employees in other bargaining units and employees historically excluded from the unit by orders of the Washington Personnel Resources Board or its predecessors.

ISSUED at Olympia, Washington, on this 23^rd day of February, 2004.

PUBLIC EMPLOYMENT RELATIONS COMMISSION

[SIGNED]

MARVIN L. SCHURKE, Executive Director by KENNETH J. LATSCH, Senior Staff Member per WAC 391-08-630(5)

This order will be the final order of the agency on the issue addressed unless a notice of appeal is filed with the Commission under WAC 391-35-210.